THE House of Commons Committee of Privileges has released a damning report on former prime minister Boris Johnson, ruling that he deliberately misled parliament over the partygate affair and recommending that he be denied a pass giving him access to parliament as a former member. The committee concluded that were he still an MP, he should be suspended for 90 days. But since Johnson resigned upon seeing a draft of the report, he will not serve the suspension. The report is nevertheless still highly significant. Here’s why.
The House of Commons Committee of Privileges is composed of MPs from the three largest parties in parliament. Its role is to uphold ethical conduct in the House of Commons alongside the Committee on Standards.
The principle accusation against Johnson is that he misled the House of Commons in relation to gatherings held in Downing Street while pandemic lockdowns were in place. Over the course of the partygate scandal, Johnson made numerous statements to the House of Commons about what he did or didn’t know and what he did and didn’t do. The narrative of his account shifted over time as new evidence came to light, creating a complex situation in which the house was certainly given incorrect information at various times.
The question of whether the house was misled, however, rested on whether any of this incorrect information was given either “knowingly”, “recklessly” or “without proper and timely correction when the facts became known”. Importantly, from the outset of its investigations the committee adopted an expansive definition which did not require direct proof of Johnson having lied.
It has concluded in no uncertain terms that he wilfully misled the house and indeed the committee itself during the course of its investigations, accusing him of being “deliberately disingenuous” in order to mislead the committee. Johnson, the committee said, cannot credibly claim that he did not know lockdown rules were being broken in Downing Street during the pandemic and that he “had personal knowledge about gatherings”.
It also dismisses his defences before the committee that he reasonably believed no rules were being broken as “no more than an artifice” designed to justify his actions in retrospect.
Misleading the house is treated exceptionally seriously because of the centrality of ministerial accountability to parliament within the uncodified British constitution.
The House of Commons standards process for ministerial accountability operates under a form of law called parliamentary privilege (from which the committee takes its name). Privilege is the mechanism which shields debate in parliament from the restrictions on free speech that apply to ordinary citizens so that MPs can speak freely. It also guarantees parliament the right to determine its own processes and procedures free from interference from the judicial and executive branches of government. Privilege is therefore widely viewed as a cornerstone of the UK’s democratic system.
As such, however, parliament is not required to observe any particular legal norms which derive from common law or statute law in dealing with cases through the standards system. However parliamentary committees commonly strive to create such fair processes, for example when dealing with witnesses at select committees, and the maximum extent of parliament’s powers under privilege have not been used for more than a century.
Johnson and his legal team contended that this process breached his right to due process. This is a right enshrined in UK law under the Human Rights Act of 1998 – a law which, incidentally, Johnson’s government attempted to abolish. However, even the lawyer representing Johnson has conceded that this right is not applicable to parliament’s procedures.
The privileges committee also pointed to the strenuous efforts made to ensure a process which is in line with the principles of right to due process and a fair hearing. Ultimately, both sides concede that parliament is fully within its rights to sanction its own members.
Johnson resigned before the committee even published its report, claiming he was being forced out. But the report could not have done this on its own. The committee proposed suspending Johnson from parliament for 90 days, which would have triggered the provisions of the 2015 Recall of MPs Act. This would have given people in his parliamentary constituency the right to sign a petition to oust him.
The 90-day suspension Johnson was to serve is much longer than the most often commonly imposed sanction over the years, which has been a five-day suspension – not long enough to trigger a recall. As the committee notes, the length is also unprecedented for a contempt of parliament charge. However it is still lower than the six-month suspension handed to Labour MP Keith Vaz in 2019 after he admitted to buying drugs from sex workers.
The length of the sentence also reflects not only Johnson’s actions in relation to speaking about partygate in parliament but to his behaviour regarding the committee too. A lengthy sentence is due because of his “impugning the Committee and thereby undermining the democratic process of the house” and his “being complicit in the campaign of abuse and attempted intimidation of the committee”.
As Johnson is no longer an MP, the committee has instead proposed that he be denied a parliamentary pass available to former members. This pass has been withdrawn from other disgraced former MPs, most recently former Labour MP Chris Williamson over his links with Iranian state television.
This article is provided by The Conversation via Reuters
Reuters
Mon Jun 19 2023
The principle accusation against Boris Johnson is that he misled the House of Commons in relation to gatherings held in Downing Street while pandemic lockdowns were in place. - REUTERS/Filepic
Karnival Sandakan gabung keunikan pelbagai etnik di Sabah
Penglibatan beberapa kaum etnik dalam Karnival Kaamatan sempena Pesta Kaamatan peringkat Daerah Sandakan 2024 menjadi landasan terbaik mengukuhkan perpaduan.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
AWANI Borneo [29/05/2024] - Limpahan Sungai Baram | Hasil negeri | Pesta Kaamatan
Awani Borneo Selasa, 29 Mei 2024 bersama Fauzi Zin;
1. Lebih 500 penduduk Kampung Long Bemang terjejas banjir
2. Sabah kemuka tuntutan 40 peratus hasil negeri ikut kiraan dan data kerajaan negeri
3. Pesta Kaamatan: Tempahan & sewa pakaian tradisi terus dapat perhatian
1. Lebih 500 penduduk Kampung Long Bemang terjejas banjir
2. Sabah kemuka tuntutan 40 peratus hasil negeri ikut kiraan dan data kerajaan negeri
3. Pesta Kaamatan: Tempahan & sewa pakaian tradisi terus dapat perhatian
Tempahan & sewa pakaian tradisi terus dapat perhatian
Setiap kali menjelang Pesta Kaamatan para peniaga pakaian tradisi sentiasa menjadi tumpuan orang ramai untuk membeli selain menyewa pakaian tradisi untuk digunakan pada majlis-majlis yang diadakan.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Sabah kemuka tuntutan 40 peratus ikut kiraan & data sendiri
Kerajaan negeri Sabah akan mengemukakan kiraan tuntutan 40 peratus hasil negeri itu daripada kerajaan persekutuan berdasarkan kiraan dan data yang dimiliki oleh kerajaan negeri.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
PRK Sungai Bakap: Kerajaan Perpaduan belum mesyuarat pilih calon
Majlis Perundingan Pimpinan Kerajaan Perpaduan belum mengadakan mesyuarat berhubung pemilihan calon bagi PRK Sungai Bakap.
Lelaki ditahan bersama 4.5 kilogram dadah berilai RM274,320
Seorang lelaki warga asing berumur 25 tahun ditahan bersama 4.5 kilogram dadah bernilai RM274,320 di jeti awam Pelabuhan Lama Tawau.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Sabah setuju wujudkan hubungan laut Kudat-Palawan
Kerajaan Negeri telah mencadangkan untuk mewujudkan hubungan laut antara Kudat dan Palawan, Filipina bagi memulihkan ekonomi daerah di utara Sabah itu.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Culik, rogol, liwat, bunuh gadis, hukuman gantung terhadap Shahril kekal
Mahkamah Persekutuan mengekalkan hukuman mati dihadapi seorang bekas ahli perniagaan yang disabitkan kesalahan membunuh seorang eksekutif pemasaran wanita 18 tahun lepas.
Jangan lalai dan leka tentang kabel penyambung elektrik
Pemangku Pengarah JBPM Sarawak, Tiong Ling Hii beri pesanan kepada penduduk yang akan pulang kampung sempena Gawai supaya jangan lalai dan jangan leka dengan peralatan elektrik, terutama kabel penyambung yang melangkaui kapasiti penggunaan.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
558 penduduk Kampung Long Bemang, Ulu Baram terjejas teruk
Seramai 558 orang penduduk yang mendiami 103 pintu rumah panjang Kampung Long Bemang, Ulu Baram, terjejas teruk apabila kampung mereka dilanda banjir setinggi 1.7 kaki, pagi pada Rabu.
#AWANIBorneo
#AWANIBorneo
Tak sedar aksi dirakam, penyampai BBC mohon maaf kepada penonton
Seorang penyampai berita saluran BBC memohon maaf atas selepas tidak sengaja menunjukkan jari tengah ketika mula bersiaran di televisyen.
Parlimen Britain sahkan laporan Boris Johnson berbohong
Ini sekaligus memberikan satu lagi tamparan kepada kerjaya politik bekas Perdana Menteri itu.
Boris Johnson didapati bersalah kerana 'penghinaan berulang' terhadap Parlimen
Siasatan mendapati bekas perdana menteri Britain Boris Johnson "berulang kali menghina" Parlimen berikutan penafiannya mengenai skandal "partygate".
Boris Johnson letak jawatan sebagai ahli parlimen
Bekas Perdana Menteri itu akui sedih apabila mengambil keputusan letak jawatan.
Kerajaan Britain diberi lebih masa serah mesej WhatsApp Boris Johnson
Hakim memberi tempoh sehingga Khamis, menyerahkan mesej dari aplikasi WhatsApp dan diari Johnson sebagai sebahagian daripada siasatannya.
Pengerusi BBC letak jawatan selepas laporan beliau terlibat dalam pinjaman untuk Boris Johnson
Pengerusi BBC Britain meletak jawatan pada Jumaat berikutan laporan yang mendapati beliau melanggar kod kerajaan.
'Tiada bukti saya mengelirukan Parlimen' - Boris Johnson
Boris Johnson menafikan beliau sengaja mengelirukan Dewan Rakyat dalam skandal parti di pejabat Downing Street.
Boris Johnson dipilih bertanding di Uxbridge, bagi pilihan raya umum akan datang
Pilihan raya umum akan datang di United Kingdom dijangka berlangsung selewat-lewatnya pada Januari 2025.
PM UK: Boris Johnson tarik diri, Rishi Sunak calon kegemaran
Percubaan kali pertama Sunak ialah pada musim panas lalu berikutan peletakan jawatan Johnson, tetapi kalah kepada Liz Truss, yang meletak jawatan Khamis lalu.
Boris Johnson tidak akan sertai perlumbaan jadi PM
Beliau memutuskan bahawa ia adalah satu keputusan yang tidak wajar untuk berbuat demikian pada masa ini.